When Life Looks Fine but Feels Meaningless — Colton Straus, LSW
This is not the kind of depression that announces itself. There is no crisis, no breakdown, no obvious reason for it. Your life is functional. Maybe even good by most measures. And underneath all of it there is a question that won't go away. What is the point of any of this. Not dramatically. Just quietly, persistently, uncomfortably. Like a frequency you cannot tune out
-
It might have started with a transition. A graduation, a promotion, a relationship milestone, something that was supposed to feel like arrival and mostly just felt like more of the same. The thing you worked toward finally happened and the feeling you expected did not show up. And now you are not sure what you were working toward in the first place.
It might be a question that keeps surfacing no matter how busy you stay. What am I actually doing this for. Who am I outside of the roles I play and the things I produce. What would I want if I stopped trying to want the right things. Questions that feel too big to sit with and too persistent to ignore.
It might be a flatness that sits underneath everything. Not sadness exactly. More like a muting. The things that used to generate feeling don't generate as much feeling anymore. The experiences that are supposed to matter feel thin. You go through the motions of a life that looks coherent and feels vaguely hollow and you cannot quite figure out when that happened or why.
It might be a sense of alienation from the people around you. Everyone else seems to be operating inside a shared agreement about what matters and what a good life looks like. You used to be inside that agreement. At some point you stepped outside of it and now you cannot quite step back in. The conversations that used to feel normal feel slightly beside the point. The things people seem to care about feel arbitrary in a way you cannot explain without sounding ungrateful or pretentious or both.
It might be the anxiety that comes with the questions themselves. The discomfort of not having answers to things that feel like they should have answers. The particular vertigo of looking at your own life from a distance and not being entirely sure what you are seeing or whether it is yours.
Existential depression is not a sign that something has gone wrong with you. It is often a sign that something has gone right. That you are paying close enough attention to your own life to notice when it does not quite fit. That the questions you are sitting with are real questions that deserve real engagement rather than being managed or suppressed or buried under enough activity that they cannot be heard.
-
Existential depression therapy with me starts by taking the questions seriously rather than trying to resolve them quickly.
A lot of therapy for depression focuses on symptom reduction. Feeling better, functioning better, getting back to baseline. That is not wrong. But existential depression is often not primarily a symptom problem. It is a meaning problem. And meaning problems do not respond to the same interventions as symptom problems. Trying to fix existential depression with techniques designed for clinical depression is like trying to answer a philosophical question with a productivity system. It misses the point.
We start by actually engaging with the questions. What is the life you are living actually for. What do you genuinely value versus what have you been performing. What would it mean to build something that actually feels like yours. Those questions are not rhetorical. They have answers. The answers are just not obvious and they cannot be found without honest examination.
The psychodynamic dimension of this work matters here. Existential questions do not arise in a vacuum. They arise in a specific person with a specific history, specific relationships, specific patterns of making meaning that were laid down before they had any framework for evaluating them. Understanding where your particular version of these questions comes from, what experiences and relationships shaped the way you relate to meaning and purpose and your own life, is part of finding your way through them. The philosophical and the personal are not separate. They are the same inquiry approached from different angles.
We also work practically. Sitting with existential questions is necessary. Sitting with them indefinitely without any movement is its own kind of trap. We work on building a life that is more genuinely yours, not through grand gestures or dramatic reinvention but through small deliberate choices that move in the direction of what actually matters to you. That movement is what generates meaning. Not the answer to the question but the living of it.
My approach is intellectually engaged, genuinely curious, and comfortable sitting with ambiguity for as long as it takes. I find these questions interesting rather than threatening. That matters when the work requires someone who will not rush you toward resolution before you have actually found it.
-
Existential depression that goes unaddressed does not resolve on its own. The questions don't go away. They just go underground, showing up as anxiety, as numbness, as a chronic low level dissatisfaction that colors everything without ever being named. The life that could have been built from genuine engagement with those questions gets built instead from avoidance of them. And the difference between those two lives is significant.
When this work gets done something clarifies. Not because the questions get answered in any final way. But because your relationship to them changes. The vertigo settles into something more like curiosity. The flatness gives way to something more like genuine engagement with your own life. The meaning that felt absent starts to be built, deliberately and in ways that feel real, out of what you actually discover matters to you.
-
The people who come in with existential depression are almost always the most honest people I work with. They are not willing to pretend that the conventional answers are enough. They are not willing to stay inside an agreement about what matters that they no longer actually believe. That honesty is not a problem. It is the beginning of something. It just needs a space where it can be taken seriously rather than managed. Honesty over comfort — steady and warm, but not afraid to name what's actually going
-
Anxiety Therapy in Logan Square & Avondale — Colton Straus
Life Transitions Therapy in Logan Square & Avondale — Colton Straus
Therapy for Young Adults in Logan Square & Avondale — Colton Straus
Therapy for College Students in Logan Square & Avondale — Colton Straus
Existential Depression Therapy in Logan Square & Avondale — Colton Straus
Relationship Patterns Therapy in Logan Square & Avondale — Colton Straus
Identity and Self Acceptance Therapy in Logan Square & Avondale — Colton Straus
Ready to take the next step? Schedule a free consultation with Colton at our Logan Square and Avondale location and see if it feels like a good fit.